PET PARENT RESOURCE CENTER

A series of educational pet nutrition blogs written by pet experts, just for pet parents.

How to Build the Perfect Stocking for Your Dog or Cat Posted on 11.06.2026

 

How to Build the Perfect Stocking for Your Dog or Cat

There's something about a stocking with your pet's name on it. It's a small way of saying they belong here, right alongside everyone else on Christmas morning.

The best pet stockings aren't the most expensive ones. They're the ones put together with a little thought about who your pet is: what they love to chew, chase, nap on, or snack on. Here's a simple way to build one your dog or cat will be glad to dig into, without overspending.

The simple formula: one of each

A well-rounded stocking covers five things. Pick one from each and you're done.

  1. Something to taste. A small bag of a treat they love, or one they haven't tried yet.

  2. Something to play with. A toy that fits how your pet likes to play.

  3. Something to work on. A chew, puzzle, or lick mat that keeps them happily busy.

  4. Something for comfort or care. A soft blanket, a brush, or a festive bandana.

  5. One little surprise. A new flavor, a new texture, or just a toy that crinkles.

Five items fill most stockings nicely. It also keeps the budget in check. Many of these are small add-ons, so you can build a full stocking for less than you might expect.

Building the dog stocking

Slot

Ideas

Good to know

Something to taste

Single-ingredient jerky, freeze-dried bites, training treats

Look for a named protein near the top of the label

Something to play with

A plush squeaker, a rope tug, a rubber ball

Size it to your dog's mouth, not the stocking

Something to work on

A long-lasting chew, a stuffable rubber toy, a lick mat

Choose a chew matched to how hard your dog chews

Comfort or care

A holiday bandana, a slicker brush, a paw balm

A brush is a nice way to make grooming part of the gift

The surprise

A new treat flavor, a crinkle toy

Try one new thing at a time

Tip for big dogs: Some favorite chews and toys won't fit in a standard stocking. Tie a bow on them and set them beside it. That counts.

Building the cat stocking

Slot

Ideas

Good to know

Something to taste

Freeze-dried treats, lickable treats, a small pouch of a new flavor

Cats can be picky; a small size is a low-risk way to try something new

Something to play with

A wand toy, catnip kickers, crinkle balls

Put wand toys away after playtime

Something to work on

A treat ball, a snuffle mat, a small puzzle feeder

Start with an easy puzzle so they don't give up

Comfort or care

A soft blanket, a grooming glove, a small scratcher

A blanket that smells like you is often a favorite

The surprise

Silvervine or a new catnip toy

Not every cat reacts to catnip, so it's worth trying both

Tip for cats: Let them explore the stocking itself. For many cats, the paper and the bag are half the fun. Just tidy up ribbon and string right after.

A few things we keep in mind

  • Hang it high until the big morning. Pets have great noses. A stocking full of treats at nose height may not make it to Christmas.

  • Supervise the unwrapping. Tissue paper, ribbon, and tags can be tempting to chew. Clear them away once the fun is over.

  • Go easy on treats. Spread stocking treats over the week instead of the morning, and count them as part of the day's food. If you're thinking about a bigger change, like a new food, ask your vet before changing your pet's diet.

  • Check toys for size and wear. Pick toys too big to swallow, and retire anything that starts to come apart.

  • Skip the people food. Holiday cookies and leftovers belong in your stocking, not theirs.

Let us help you fill it

Not sure where to start? Tell us a little about your pet, how they play, what they love, and what they turn their nose up at, and our team will help you put together a stocking that fits them and your budget.

Visit any Treats Unleashed store in St. Louis, Columbia, or Kansas City this season. 

Here's to a Merry Christmas for every member of the family, two legs or four.

Tagged: Pet Store holiday pet stockings stocking stuffers